Read Our Story
directly to a page.
Chapter 46 – Heavenly Reunions?

“Don, Dad, Master, you’re here! OK, let’s play!”
If you read through this website you can see how much I loved Gabby. Losing her has been tremendously painful, more that words can say, and I have been profoundly affected by it. As I searched the web for comfort and grief support, I found I was far from the only person overwhelmed with grief after losing a beloved dog (or cat.) I was searching for signs and answers that she was OK and I would see her again someday, and found many people out there doing the same. This is my own little contribution to the subject. I’ve had some amazing experiences in my lifetime and now is the time to share them. Perhaps they will help if you are in a similar situation.
In this section, I will discuss things that many people struggle with, especially those of us who have lost a beloved pet. Is there a God? Is there something more than material existence, is there an afterlife? And especially for those of us who loved and lost pets, will we seen them again someday? You may have found this page because you have lost a dog or cat of your own that was very special. This page is especially for you. I know in dealing with my own loss, I read books and searched for webpages as I was looking for reassurance, and the subject is one I have grappled most my entire life.
Please note that despite what I will write in this, the final chapter, this site is about Gabby and our life together, not spiritual matters. It is all very personal and I really debated whether to put in the parts about me watching “The Devil’s Hand” and learning about Neil Hamilton and Don Bosco, the messages that flooded my mind the day after she passed, the Driver Dream and my subsequent conversation with Nancy, etc. The reason I decided to include them is they are part of the story, and I think it is a better story when told in its entirety and I don’t censor myself.
I will start by saying that I am not a religion teacher of any stripe. I wouldn’t even know how to categorize what I am about to write here other than “putting it all out there.” Many others in the public sphere have shared their experiences and they have helped me. Some of them I have even quoted or linked here or on other pages of this site. It would be hypocritical of me to read these stories and gain the benefit of their testimony and experience, without being willing to speak out myself.
The first question, obviously, is the belief in God and Heaven at all, or that something that lies beyond our physical existence. There has to be a God and Heaven for us to see our pets there someday! Some people just believe and accept this without question, some of us struggle with issues of God, faith, religion, and what comes after this life. I have tended to fall in the latter category, those who struggle sometimes. It can be so hard to make sense of it all, in a world with so much suffering and pain, a world that is so unfair, chaotic, and that doesn’t make sense.

Making my way to the top of the Eiffel Tower in August 2014
In August 2014 I was in Paris, making my way up to the top of the Eiffel Tower. When I got to the top I looked out over the city to La Defense out in the distance. I contemplated existence and the meaning of it all at that very moment.

La Defense, Paris
“Donald, there are things that happen sometimes that no one can explain.”
These are words my grandfather said that have stuck with me all my life. I was discussing my doubts about God and faith with my grandparents, and they listened. At a certain point, my grandfather, who had remained silent as I went on and on, said, “Donald, there are things that happen sometimes that no one can explain.”
He had a way of communicating very effectively, and always knew how to drive the point home while using very few words. He always said “Donald” when he wanted something to stick. And stick it did, I knew exactly what he meant, and why.
It has been a long journey and at times I have felt atheistic, but I have come to fall on the side of belief, with the idea that God works through natural forces to create the world. I am Catholic as part of my cultural identity, if not strict practice. I have come to develop a simple Christian view and trust in God’s mercy, grace and forgiveness, while doing the best I can in all that I do and not judging others. Though I have told stories about answered prayers as I wrote this story, I don’t consider myself a religious person, especially from an organized religion standpoint. Let’s just say I have faith, though sometimes I doubt like Thomas despite some amazing experiences I have had. It is the curse of a technical, analytical mind.
Helping me to believe are things that happen that can’t be explained, that tell you that there is more. I related the story of Neil Hamilton in the chapter about Gabby’s second kidney problem, where he narrowly avoided committing suicide due to a chance encounter with a priest. His life was changed forever in that moment.
Chris Pratt
Actor Chris Pratt had this story for Esquire Magazine:
He was indeed destined for great things. Shortly thereafter, he was waiting tables at Bubba Gump Shrimp Company, met a director, and got a part. You know the rest of the story. He is a huge star now, one of the hottest in Hollywood with lead roles in The Lego Movie, Guardians of the Galaxy, Jurassic World, etc.
There is a good thread about this on the allnurses.com message board. A few skeptics chime in, but you can tell that most of the hospice nurses here believe these visions are real. The discussion starts here:
http://allnurses.com/general-nursing-discussion/deathbed-visions-196680.html
So many stories of this type are so similar. Most skeptics say that it is just the dying process of brain or drugs, but I don’t buy it. Too many stories, too similar, too relevant to the people experiencing them, and many of them were not on meds. I don’t think the brain is that good to fool itself this way, and where there is smoke, there is fire. There is more going on here than can be easily explained by biology.
Roger Ebert
Roger Ebert, who refused to be labeled either as a believer or an atheist, or even as an agnostic, had a remarkable vision shortly before he died. You can read about it below.
Here is what he said himself in 2009, years before his visions and death. Something clearly changed.
Susan R. Stoltz
Writer Susan R. Stoltz had an amazing experience after her dog Crusher passed away.
Shortly after he died I was doing a real estate appraisal in northern Wyoming. I walked out of a real estate office after picking up a key and an elderly man of Native American descent looked at me and asked me if I was aware that a small tan and white dog followed me wherever I went. I was instantly in tears and replied, “One used to follow me but had recently died.” He said “He is with you now, right by your feet as he was in life.”
You can read the whole article at http://www.lifewithdogs.tv/
Betty and Becky
This one happened in my own family. In 1982 my Aunt Betty was in London on vacation. Her best friend, Becky, was back in the United States and fighting a losing battle against cancer. One morning, my Aunt had a very realistic dream in which Becky, now looking healthy and whole, came to her and said, “I came to see you and say goodbye.” Then Becky left and my aunt woke up.
These anecdotes, and so many more like them help me believe in something more than material existence, in God, Heaven, and there being something waiting for us when we pass on.
By David Kessler
Final Gifts: Understanding the Special Awareness, Needs, and Communications of the Dying
By Maggie Callanan and Patricia Kelley
If there is something more, the rest is easy for me. If there is a God and a Heaven, I have no doubt our dogs will be there, too. As Robert Louis Stevenson said, “You think dogs will not be in heaven? I tell you they will be there long before any of us.” I don’t know anyone can look into those eyes and get to know a dog, and not think they have a soul worthy of Heaven, or that God does not love them too.
My own experiences
I myself have had things happen to me that do not have a scientific explanation, and that I cannot simply write off to coincidence. I told one story in “Psychic Bond?” but it wasn’t the only one. Three times in my life I asked God for reassurance regarding my life and those I love, and my prayers were answered in rather direct fashion. One of these was actually about dogs and the afterlife. I will tell these stories below. I have never done so publicly before, mostly because I did not want people to think I was crazy! But it seems like a lot of people like myself have had amazing experiences, but have been afraid to share them for just this reason. Here is an excerpt from Hello From Heaven: A New Field of Research Confirms That Life and Love are Eternal. I highly recommend this book, by the way. It was written by Bill and Judy Guggenhein. (ADC stands for after death communication.)


Nuns and signs
When I was in Catholic grade school in sixth grade, a nun I will never forget, Sister St. Jude, told a story that would turn out to have big implications for my future.
She was a math teacher, but she talked about religion and life a lot, too. (She was a nun, after all…) One day she told the class a story about how horrible she felt when she lost her mother. She asked God to give her a sign that her mother was OK, and in Heaven. She asked for something specific and unlikely that she could not miss… that she see only one red rose at the viewing the next day. This was pretty unlikely, given how many roses there usually are at funerals. Then, when she went to the viewing, she did not see any red roses at all! She thought she was not given her sign, then later someone tapped her on the shoulder and said, “Look at that single red rose sticking out in the middle of that bouquet. Isn’t that odd?”
Bible scholars will recognize the similarity to the story of Gideon and the fleece, from the Book of Judges. Gideon’s faith was weak, so he often asked for signs.
Gideon sounds a lot like me.
First time I tried this…
OK, I thought this was unlikely enough. I prayed and asked God to please send me a sign, that if what I was worrying about would come true, that I meet a member of my fraternity at work the next day. I thought I would see a guest in the park wearing my Greek letters like I did the year before, which outside of a college environment was an extremely rare occurrence.
I walked through the park on patrol the whole day, not seeing anyone wearing the Greek letters. My final shift was at the back gate, checking employee IDs. The day was almost over and I remembered my prayer of the night before. I thought to myself, “Well, I did not get my sign, but seriously, you can’t expect things like that to happen…” and put it all out of my mind.
About fifteen minutes later an employee wearing a lifeguard uniform walked past, holding up his ID, saying, “See what a nice guy I am? You do not even have to ask me for my ID!” I thanked him and he walked 200 feet to the entrance gate. Then he turned around and walked back, stopping at my guard shack.
“Can I help you?” I asked.
“Weren’t you in a fraternity up in Pittsburgh?” came the question.
“Yes,” I replied.
“Which one?’
“Phi Delta Theta. Why?”
“Because I am a Phi Delt too.”
“Really?” I asked. “Where? Give me the handshake!” And he did!
I asked him how he knew we were in the same fraternity. He said that at the moment he got to the park entrance, he realized that the year before he saw me wearing a shirt with our Greek letters. We chatted about our chapters and college life until he had to report to work. As he walked away, I turned and thought to myself, “Wow, it is really cool to have another Phi Delt working here…”
And then, I realized what had happened and stopped dead in my tracks. It was like the whole world came to a standstill for a moment. I received exactly what I had asked for, and my prayer was answered. Not only was it answered, it was answered in a way that made it extremely difficult to write off as mere coincidence. I didn’t see someone walking around the park wearing Greek letters. That would be pretty easy to write off to coincidence. HE came to ME, out of the blue, and asked if I was in a fraternity. He asked me on that specific day in the middle of the summer, 15 minutes before I was supposed to end my work day, and there was nothing present anywhere at the time to identify ourselves as fraternity members.
What you are probably wondering now is if what I asked for a sign about actually happened. It did, but not when I was expecting it. I expected it to happen as soon as I returned to school at the end of the summer. It did not happen then. I was disappointed and wrote off my answered prayer as an accident or coincidence. The joke was on me though, because it came true the last day of finals my senior year, three years later, the day before I moved out of town to start my new job. It was literally at the very last possible moment, and when it happened I was in shock. I did nothing to make it occur, it happened spontaneously because I was in the right place at the right time. I had given up and forgotten about my goal.
After my initial disappointment years prior, I thought it was impossible for the sign to come true. I never made any more efforts to achieve my goal, but I got what I asked for anyway spontaneously and at the last possible moment in my time at college. It happened on God’s time, not mine, and I can’t take any credit for it at all.
I told a friend about this and he said, “God went out of his way for you!”
Second time, and 2 for 2
The next evening, Gram and I were watching a Simpsons rerun. The episode unfolds. Bart gets a fake driver’s license and the kids rent a car. They are headed to Disney World. Milhouse is looking at an old AAA Triptik and says, “Wait, stop the car! Let’s not go to Orlando. Let’s go to Nashville!”
“What’s in Nashville?” Bart asks.
“A fair!” Milhouse replies. “And not just a fair, but a WORLD’S fair!”
I got goosebumps when this happened and again, time seemed to stop for a moment. My friend Ted was there at the time and we discussed it later. He knew about the first sign I asked for and how it came true, and when I told him what happened that evening, he nodded, saying, “I believe in that stuff.” He’s never really had any doubts about God, faith or anything, and he has had some amazing spiritual experiences of his own.
So, out of my entire life up until then, I pled for divine reassurance about the two things that meant the very most to me. Each time, I got it, against all odds.
Third time, about Gabby and the afterlife
The third time was about Gabby and whether we would see each other again after she passed.
In September 2008 I was in Las Vegas on vacation. I missed Gabby, as I always did when I traveled, and was looking forward to going home and seeing her again. It weighed heavily on my mind… that someday in the future, when I got home from vacation she would not be there to greet me anymore. She would be 11 in November, and my sister’s dachshund Sally lived to be 13, and my Aunt Linda’s dachshund Pepper, to 14. That meant I could be losing her very soon, if her life followed the pattern we had seen in our family.
One of the events planned for the trip was a Barry Manilow concert at the Las Vegas Hilton. The show was September 26, 2008. He was just opening up a new show celebrating his past hits, called “Ultimate Manilow- The Hits.” I liked many of his songs, and Mark Evanier wrote a great story about his experience going to a performance at http://www.newsfromme.com/
Remembering the two signs I received years before and Gabby’s mortality very heavy on my mind that evening, I said a little prayer as we walked into the theater. “God… if dogs go to heaven, and Gabby and I will be together there someday… would you please give me a sign during the concert?” I did not ask for anything specific as I could not think of anything to ask for, just that he let me know.
I sat down, realizing it would be pretty hard to get a sign about being with my dog in the afterlife during a Barry Manilow concert. It was a stupid thing to ask for, and I would likely be disappointed this time. I shook my head and laughed at myself. Oh, well.
About halfway through the concert, Barry pulled out a stool and sat down near the edge of the stage. I do not remember his exact words, so I am going to paraphrase the best I can. The audience’s reaction needs no paraphrasing!
After he sat down he addressed the audience. “I am going to sing this next song without the orchestra. When people hear it, they think it is about a romantic relationship, lovers who had parted getting back together again. It is true that it is what it is about, but to me, it has another meaning too. There are those we have loved who are no longer with us, and it’s about being reunited with them again someday.”
My ears perked up. This really gained my attention.
He continued, “As for me, I miss my Grandfather… and I miss X” (don’t remember who he said here.)
Then there was a long pause. I was waiting with anticipation… would he say it?
His voice broke a little as he said it. “I miss my dogs.”
“AWWWWWWWWWW!” went the whole audience.
“The song is called ‘Somewhere Down the Road’ and I hope you enjoy it.”
Here is the song.

They gave everyone a glowstick when they entered the concert. Given what I had experienced, I made sure I saved mine. It is now in a special dresser drawer that is dedicated to Gabby. In the picture above, the glowstick is resting on the shirt I wore in Canada the day I had the sudden, accurate premonition she was in trouble. You can see me wearing it in the picture of me holding her in front of my Mini Cooper S. To me, the shirt and the memories of that day are a reminder of how connected we were, and how special our relationship was.
I knew Barry was born Jewish, and afterwards I did a little research on his religious beliefs. It seems some websites were claiming he was an atheist, based on jokes he made during interviews about the president of his record company being God, and comments he made about not being involved in Judaism, his birth religion. This didn’t make sense at all given what he said at the concert, and there was no mistaking what I heard. What he said at the concert was a very non-atheist thing to say. I have since found references that argue against atheism, both in letters and interviews, as linked below.
http://www.digitalspy.com/
http://barrynethomepage.com/
http://barrynethomepage.com/
From an interview with GQ:
Q: When you were growing up, were you a religious kid?
A: Absolutely not.
Q: Did your family go to temple?
A: They did, but I didn’t get it. I didn’t get religion. When they took me to shul, it seemed to me they were always telling me that I was doing something terribly wrong and I had to atone for it. And I kept saying, “But I’m a nice fellow. I don’t think I need to atone for very much.” So I didn’t get the rest of it. I went on my own and figured out my own spiritual path.
The entire interview can be read at: http://www.manilow.nl/
Praying for young stars, keeping people in thoughts and prayers, and speaking of a spiritual path do not sound very atheistic to me. It is well known that he is an extremely private person, and does not even share the names of his dogs with the public. Given this he probably does not want to discuss his spiritual beliefs openly, and besides, the purpose of this site is not to speculate about the religious beliefs of Barry Manilow. Personally, I think he hopes to be reunited with Bagel and his other dogs someday, and was willing to share that much during the concert. I just knew that if I was going to put this story out there, it could seem like a contradiction given some sites claim he is an atheist. Regardless of what it says elsewhere, I know what I heard at the concert and what it meant to me. That’s my story and I’m sticking to it!
November 7, 2017 Update
Below this paragraph you will see a second video, a clip from a Manilow concert. I found it on November 7th, 2017, which would have been Gabby’s 20th birthday. I searched for years for a clip of Barry in concert giving the same introduction to the song, but never found it. Feeling a bit melancholic on Gabby’s 20th birthday, I searched YouTube for “Somewhere Down the Road.” I just wanted to hear the song and remember that day, and what it meant to me. The video came up in the first search results and when I watched, I was thrilled to see he gave an introduction very, very similar to the one I heard way back then. I posted it here the very next day, the only addition I have made to the site since I put it online in December of 2015. Now you can see it for yourself, and now I can go back and relive that day at times when I miss her most. I am glad I found it, especially on her birthday. It was put on YouTube in 2011 and somehow I never came across it before, despite many searches.
I must admit that at times I would second-guess what I heard at the concert, though the memory is still very vivid in my mind. Finding and watching this video was a great affirmation! I can’t say I ever seriously doubted what I heard and what I felt at that moment, but for a long time I have wished I could go back and hear it again. Now, I can. What a gift!
The introduction starts around 1:20 and he mentions his dogs starting at 2:15. Wherever you are, Barry Manilow, thanks for conveying the message in such a beautiful way… though I doubt it was the first time you have done that for someone.
See you somewhere down the road, Gabby!
Later on I was lying in bed, unable to sleep, thinking of her and missing her. I just wanted to know I was going to see her again and she was OK. I had already had the sign at the concert, but I just wanted a little more reassurance. “Maybe I should ask for another sign,” I thought. “If I asked and got it, THEN I would know for sure!”
I quickly steered myself from this line of thought, arguing with myself. “No, no, NO ! You did that three times and got it, don’t push your luck a fourth time. Given how you are feeling, if you don’t get it you will be devastated. Just remember what Reverend Tami said, and have a little faith. Besides, if the previous three are not enough then a fourth won’t make a difference anyway.”
So, now that I wasn’t going to ask… I wondered… “If I was going to ask for a sign again, what would I ask for? What is something I could not possibly miss?” Something a million to one, that I never, ever see?”
The next day proceeded as normal. I went to my favorite restaurant, Grande Italian Restaurant, for lunch. I eat there four or five times per week and am friends with all the staff. Nancy, who I mentioned in Driver Dream, works there.

Citroen GS Image credit: Wikimedia
Afraid to put it on the line, I had not even “officially” asked for a sign. Yet I got my answer. Looking back to the moment I saw it there, I feel such a sense of wonder, and a feeling that God knew of my pain and wanted to reassure me.

The dark green Citroen GS was parked where the blue Jeep is in the picture above
I wish I would have had the presence of mind to take a picture of the Citroen right under the Grande sign when it happened, but I had forgotten about my little self-discussion of the night before. And believe me, if you wanted to park it somewhere to get my attention, right in front of Grande Italian Restaurant is probably the most conspicuous place you could do it, other than directly in front of my house!
At this point I should add that these four times are the only time I asked for direct reassurance in this way. I don’t go through life constantly asking God for signs and reassurance. The only times I prayed and asked in this fashion were when it was something tremendously important to me. That’s why it is impossible for me to write them off as mere coincidence.
Why me?
I don’t know.
In short, if there is a God and a Heaven, our beloved pets will be there for us… of that I am sure. As so many have said before, it would not be Heaven without them.
Thinking forward to the day Gabby and I am reunited, I start to wonder what form it will take…


I did not pick it because of its style or color. I bought it because it was very well maintained by a retired engineer, I liked the way it drove and the price was right. I gotta say though, it was kind of a cool coincidence, given my dream!

My sister sent me this text, with a cartoon about meeting your dog at the pearly gates and them remembering you no matter how long you have been parted. It is a famous cartoon by cartoonist Charles Barsotti. It has an interesting story about it, linked below at The Bark:
I bragged about Gabby when she was here, and I brag about her now. Hopefully she is going on and on about me up there!
Coming with Gram and Pop?
and let her know that I will always love her.
And when it’s my time to pass over into your paradise,
please allow her to accompany those
who will bring me home.

May you and your beloved pets have a joyful reunion as well.